Can You Buy A Car Cheaper Than A Train Ticket?

CCFS's Calum Brown is on a mission, even if it was agreed after numerous pints in the pub. Can you purchase a car cheaper than a train ticket, and beat it to your destination? 

Words: Calum Brown
Photography: Stephanie Graham and Richard Gunn

peterborough.jpg

No one likes taking the train. They’re clearly lying if they say otherwise. Or on mind-altering drugs. Besides suffering the aggravation of shouty, spoilt children, the nose-curling stench of cheap cleaning products and being subjected to cackling groups of yobbos discussing post-watershed topics, your journey is dictated by a time schedule as vague as Nicolas Cage’s face.

This perception caused some friction, however, in a drunken argument I recently had in my local – can a car beat a train? I agreed to take on the challenge.

The chosen route was CCW’s hometown of Peterborough to Stranraer in Scotland. The rules were simple: I had to buy a car and cover the insurance and fuel for the return journey with the money left over from the ticket price. The amount I had to play with totalled a paltry £243. 

Searching the classifieds yielded a ropey-looking Peugeot 406 1.9 diesel for £160. Legendary for using little to no fuel, it felt like a winner. Day insurance cover robbed £30 from my budget, leaving £53 for diesel funds to cover 800 miles. Boy, fuel was going to tight. 

Setting off from Peterborough station at 08:16 – at the same time as the train – Team Peugeot battled out of rush hour Peterborough in search of the A1, only for a plume of steam to billow out from under the bonnet. Investigation revealed that the connecting pipes at the base of the radiator had split.

Relieving a nearby petrol station of all of its two-litre bottles of water, I plugged on regardless. Half an hour had elapsed by the time my giant kettle had rejoined the A1, but the mood inside was still calm and collected – because the ageing 406 had a trump card. The train had to commute via Glasgow and Ayr, but the Pug could cut cross the A66 before turning off the M74 towards Dumfries – cutting a whopping 90 miles off the train’s journey. Game on.

Calum's Aunt and Uncle, who have experience with mechanicals, gave the Pug a thumbs down. 

Calum's Aunt and Uncle, who have experience with mechanicals, gave the Pug a thumbs down. 

The coolant warning light blared red – despite having covered it with masking tape to distract myself from the issue – whenever the radiator divested itself of water, but luckily, the fuel consumption rate wasn’t as ferocious – roughly 50mpg at a steady 55mph.

Passing the Scottish border and pushing on into Dumfries and Galloway, the fuel gauge wasn’t budging and the mileage towards Stranraer was shrinking with every passing road sign.

Then with just half a mile to go, I spotted the railway line – and saw that there was a train on it. In the ensuing panicked rush to the finish, the Peugeot hit the first of several speed humps so hard that it landed with a crash violent enough to cause the boot to fly open and fire my tools out onto the ground.

With the ABS refusing to work on the soaking wet road, I slid the 406 to a halt and legged it towards the platform in the lashing rain, slipping on the pavement and cutting myself open on the railings in the process – only to discover, holding my arm to stop myself leaving a trail of blood behind me, that the train I’d spotted wasn’t, in fact, the one I was racing – that one was still a good hour and a half away.

Arriving at Stranraer train station, Calum managed to cut himself open. At least the car was unscathed... 

Arriving at Stranraer train station, Calum managed to cut himself open. At least the car was unscathed... 

I couldn’t help but relish the victory – right up to the point when the radiator burst completely. Spraying coolant onto the ground as though someone was emptying a bucket. But it didn’t matter – a Franco-Scottish alliance of man and machine had just beaten the might of the railway network.

Then I remembered that I had to make it home again to win the bet...
 

With the rampant acceleration of a slug in a bag, and stuck at 55mph to conserve fuel, the journey's atmosphere is echoed in Calum's face. 

With the rampant acceleration of a slug in a bag, and stuck at 55mph to conserve fuel, the journey's atmosphere is echoed in Calum's face. 

With water seeping out of radiator pipes at an alarming rate despite refilling the beast with fluid - including some blood -  and only a third of a tank left in the half-dead 406 1.9TD GLX, the journey back from Stranraer to Peterborough did not appear an attractive prospect.

So far, although the Pug had been behaving itself, the experience had been just the other side of pleasant. Now, despite beating the train in the pub bet from hell, the return journey was before me. With no radio, a boot that kept opening over bumps, electric windows pursuing a life of their own, overheating issues and an intense smell of smoke and despair, thanks mainly  to the previous chain-smoking owner, the £160 Pug 406 could tick all the boxes to define dung on wheels. Except, on a molecular level, excrement is usually fizzling with energy.

In essence, to win my drunkenly accepted train verses car challenge, I only had £35 in diesel left to complete the return journey, some 398 miles. Up to this point, the Peugeot had seemed to enjoy gulping down coolant more than it did diesel, but its rate of fuel consumption was still an unknown.

This was always going to be tight on the fuel front. But not this tight... 

This was always going to be tight on the fuel front. But not this tight... 

Upon leaving the Glasgow South Western Line terminus, team Peugeot had eight hours to reach Peterborough, and despite my complaints around the vehicle’s maladies, the car ran sweet as a nut. And, without a radio, it gave me time to contemplate exactly why buying a cheap car beats paying handover- fist for a train ticket. 

Besides not having to tackle the chaos of railway  stations and the miserable, heart stopping experience of getting from one platform to the other in order to catch a connection, I also had my own space and the chance to lap up the countryside train passengers never get to relish. 

The money saved also bought me a meal – a big, inexpensive one, seeing as I had some blood loss to make up for.

 

As Peterborough station came into view, the relief that the bet was won overwhelmed me. I’m surprised I wasn’t arrested for screeching to a halt outside the main entrance and dancing a jig bellowing ‘Ya Dancer!’ into the air.

While my 406 may have been mostly ruined, it was still a better option than taking public transport. Coming in at £10 cheaper overall and five hours quicker, I can now sell the Pug to reclaim even more cash. Anyone fancy a bloodstained, smokey, leaky Peugeot 406 1.9TD GLX? 

What do you mean, no? 

Photographer, Stephanie Graham, thoroughly enjoyed a thorough soaking everytime the 406 required a radiator top-up.  

Photographer, Stephanie Graham, thoroughly enjoyed a thorough soaking everytime the 406 required a radiator top-up.  

Recently Added

Placeholder cbe6c9521c21456cf9170dc847e3e1de3931371c967e81955c16862b992b5364Sponsored Ad
1993
£Auction
320
  • 0
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 N/A
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: TA1104585
Lot Number: - The vendor is warranting the 109,974 miles covered by this four owner E20 Cabriolet...
0
01553 621 415
View details
Dsc05063   small jpegSponsored Ad
1956
£120,000
  • 5,232
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 N/A
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: TA1101040
The XK140 General Background The Jaguar XK140 premiered in 1954 as the successor of the XK120. Th...
6
01424 870600
View details
AudittsideSponsored Ad
2006
£6,250
  • 33,769
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 Manual
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: DIY1096055
Stunning throughout, 3 keys, every Tax disc and full MoT history from new and 16 separate Audi sa...
11
07711020000
View details
ImageSponsored Ad
1968
£3,900
  • 87,000
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 Manual
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: DIY1104416
Morris Mini 1968 Mk 2 . In need of complete restoration, excellent interior art from drivers seat...
4
01929439962
View details
Placeholder cbe6c9521c21456cf9170dc847e3e1de3931371c967e81955c16862b992b5364Sponsored Ad
1984
£Auction
TE
  • 0
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 N/A
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: TA1104583
Lot Number: - The vendor is warranting the 87,648 miles covered by this automatic W123 Estate. It...
0
01553 621 415
View details
Placeholder cbe6c9521c21456cf9170dc847e3e1de3931371c967e81955c16862b992b5364Sponsored Ad
1979
£Auction
SE
  • 38,700
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 N/A
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: TA1104582
Lot Number: - This automatic W116 records just three owners from new, the last registered since 2...
0
01553 621 415
View details
Placeholder cbe6c9521c21456cf9170dc847e3e1de3931371c967e81955c16862b992b5364Sponsored Ad
1992
£Auction
SE TURBO
  • 0
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 N/A
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: TA1104580
Lot Number: - Library photo: 1,588cc. Benefits from recent waxoyling, replacement heater switch a...
0
01553 621 415
View details
Placeholder cbe6c9521c21456cf9170dc847e3e1de3931371c967e81955c16862b992b5364Sponsored Ad
1963
£Auction
  • 0
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 N/A
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: TA1104579
Lot Number: - Five keepers from new, the last owner registered since 2000. We are advised by the ...
0
01553 621 415
View details
Placeholder cbe6c9521c21456cf9170dc847e3e1de3931371c967e81955c16862b992b5364Sponsored Ad
1994
£Auction
V8I
  • 48,000
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 N/A
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: TA1104578
Lot Number: - The vendor advises that this manual V8 Discovery has had very little use in the las...
0
01553 621 415
View details
Placeholder cbe6c9521c21456cf9170dc847e3e1de3931371c967e81955c16862b992b5364Sponsored Ad
1987
£Auction
4.0
  • 73,776
  • Transmission 69197354786223e29b85070a0695cc247a4c2b215c743673c2d02e864b4cd687 N/A
  • Steering ca68a9643bbb915d30839040f432af59e679db8cf98e23a4378cbef2ed805059 RHD
  • Refcode: TA1104577
Lot Number: - This 5.3 V12 XJS has been described by the vendor as being in lovely condition. Own...
0
01553 621 415
View details
See All Classic Cars for Sale